
These sticky toffee pudding madeleines with homemade vanilla custard ice cream are the best desserts I have made all year. I was inspired by the shell like patterns on the madeleines and wanted to create a seashell holding a pearl. So these whimsical madeleine ice cream sandwiches were born.
The madeleines will soak up all the beautiful sauce and ice cream creating this beautiful and classic stick toffee pudding texture. It’s got an indulgent caramel/butterscotch richness that pairs perfectly with the icey vanilla ice cream.
Yield: 20 madeleines or 10 seashells ice cream sandwiches
INGREDIENTS:
MADELEINES-
- 130g Medjool Dates
- 100ml Water
- 2g Baking Soda
- 115g Unsalted Butter
- 20g Dark Brown Sugar
- 2tbsp Black Treacle/Molasses
- 120g AP/Plain Flour
- 50g Caster Sugar
- 4g Baking Powder
- 1 Large Egg, room temp
- 1tsp Vanilla Extract
- Pinch of Salt
- Extra Butter for brushing on madeleine moulds
VANILLA CUSTARD ICE CREAM- Click here for the full recipe
- 4 Large Egg Yolks
- 132g Caster Sugar
- 300ml Double Cream/Heavy Cream
- 300ml Whole Milk
- 2tsp Whole Vanilla Bean or Vanilla Bean Paste
- Pinch of Salt
BUTTERSCOTCH SAUCE-
- 150g Dark Brown Sugar
- 50g Butter
- 200ml Double/Heavy Cream
- 1tbsp Black Treacle/Molasses
- Pinch of Salt

STEPS:
MADELEINES-
- Pit dates and roughly chop into smaller pieces
- Add the dates and water to a saucepan, cook it over medium heat until softened. The mixture does not need to be smooth some chunkiness is encouraged
- Add baking soda and quickly stir it in, the mixture will bubble. As the bubbles calms down and the mixture is a paste consistency, transfer it into a bowl and leave in the fridge to quickly cool down
- In a saucepan, add butter, dark brown sugar, and black treacle. Cook over medium heat while slowly stirring to allow all the sugar to dissolve and the butter to melt. The butter will start to bubble and simmer, cook the mixture until the bubbling slows down and it starts to smell like delicious brown butter. Transfer it into a bowl and leave in the fridge to cool quickly
- In a large bowl, add flour, sugar, and baking powder. Whisk aggressively until well combined
- Add the date paste from step 3 into the dry mix and whisk
- Add the egg and whisk until everything is just incorporated
- Add vanilla, salt and the butter mixture from step 4 to the batter and whisk until just incorporated
- Scrape the bowl and press a piece of clingfilm right onto the batter. Place this in the fridge overnight
- Pre-heat oven to 170°C (with a fan) or 190°C (without a fan) and brush a thin layer of melted butter over the madeleine baking tray
- Tap the tray aggressively to allow the batter to settle
- Pop it into the oven to bake at 170°C (with a fan) or 190°C (without a fan) for 4 min then rotate the tray to bake for another 3-4 min
- Once they are fully baked, let it cool for a few minutes then flip the tray and gently tap to release the cakes
- Leave it to cool completely
VANILLA CUSTARD ICE CREAM-
- See here for my vanilla custard ice cream or you can use store bought vanilla ice cream
BUTTERSCOTCH SAUCE-
- Add dark brown sugar, butter, cream, treacle, and salt to a saucepan
- Cook on low heat while constantly stirring. Allow everything to melt and combine. Once it starts to gently simmer transfer it off the heat and transfer into a heat proof container
ASSMEBLE-
- For the seashell look shown in the image, slice a bit of the hump off of the madeleine so create a flat surface. Place the exposed surface facing up
- Cover the madeleine with some sauce
- Scoop the ice cream with a tablespoon measuring spoon to create the “pearl” and place it in the centre
- Place the second madeleine over the ice cream will the shell side up. Allow the ends of the madeleines to meet to create a open seashell look
- Pour the butterscotch sauce all over to fully cover the top Madeleine
